My Mom Outsourced Emotional Support to God

Sometimes you don't need advice. You just need someone to be there.

When I told my mother I was struggling, she told me to pray. I wasn't looking for divine intervention. I just wanted my mum. An essay about faith, emotional absence, and the human connection we sometimes forget to give each other.

When I closed my business, I was not doing particularly well. That’s the polite version. The less polite version is that I was anxious, exhausted, and wondering whether the thing I was feeling was depression or just life kicking me repeatedly in the balls. I was trying to take things one day at a time because looking any further ahead felt like a terrible idea. You know that wonderful period in adulthood when everything you’ve worked for starts falling apart and you’re somehow expected to remain a functioning member of society? Yeah, that.

My mother noticed something was wrong. She asked why I looked so stressed, so I told her. I told her the business was gone, that I was struggling, that I was worried about my mental health and wasn’t entirely sure what came next. It wasn’t an easy conversation to have, but she’d asked, and for once I thought perhaps I should be honest about how I was feeling.

She looked at me and said, “Shukri kena sembahyang, and doa pada Allah.” (Shukri, you need to pray and ask Allah for help.)

And that was pretty much the end of that conversation. No “I’m sorry you’re going through this.” No “You’ll find your way.” Not even a reassuring lie about how everything happens for a reason. Just a referral to the Almighty. It occurred to me that my mother had effectively outsourced emotional support to God, which, from an operational standpoint, is probably a brilliant arrangement. Omnipresent, supposedly available around the clock, and no need for her to personally handle any of the more complicated enquiries. Unfortunately, there’s no customer service hotline, and I haven’t exactly had the best relationship with Him. I wish I did. Perhaps that would have made the referral easier to accept.

Here’s the thing, though. I wasn’t asking for a theological solution. I wasn’t questioning the existence of God, seeking spiritual enlightenment, or looking for someone to explain the divine wisdom behind my business going tits-up. I was telling my mother I was scared. I was an adult man, admittedly, but still her son, sitting in front of her and admitting that I wasn’t coping particularly well. What I needed wasn’t a miracle. I would have settled for a little reassurance, perhaps even a hug, or just five minutes of her telling me that things would eventually be all right. She didn’t have to believe it herself. I just needed to hear it from my mum.

I don’t think she meant to hurt me. In fact, I genuinely believe that in her mind, directing me towards God was an act of love. She’s a woman of faith, and I imagine prayer has helped her through difficulties I know very little about. I don’t begrudge her that. But good intentions don’t automatically translate into comfort. Sometimes they just leave the person on the receiving end feeling even more alone, with the added inconvenience of regretting having opened their mouth in the first place.

The unfortunate truth is that this wasn’t some isolated incident. Growing up, emotional support wasn’t exactly a thriving department in our household. My father, bless him, is about as emotionally accessible as a reinforced concrete wall. Not the kind you lean against for support, mind you. The kind you eventually stop talking to because, despite your best efforts, walls famously don’t respond. My mother, meanwhile, had God. Between the two of them, there wasn’t much room for an actual conversation about feelings, fears, disappointments, or any of the other inconvenient things that come with being human. Eventually, I stopped trying. After all, what’s the point of reaching out to someone when you already know where they’re going to redirect you?

What makes this particularly difficult to reconcile is how my mother has always spoken about her own mother. My Tok Tina, from everything my mother has told us over the years, was a wonderful woman. My mother lost her while she was still in college, but the affection with which she remembers her has never diminished. She would tell us how wonderful Tok Tina was, how much she meant to her, and how she always wanted to be just like her mother. It’s something I’ve heard throughout my life, and I’ve never had any reason to doubt how deeply she loved and admired her.

And I suppose that’s what I struggle to understand. My mother grew up with an idea of motherhood that she treasured so much she wanted to recreate it for her own children. Yet somehow, my experience has been different. I don’t know whether losing Tok Tina so young changed something in her, or whether my mother and I simply have very different ideas of what it means to be there for someone. Perhaps she’s spent her entire life trying to live up to a woman she lost before she was ready to say goodbye. I genuinely don’t know. All I know is that she speaks about the mother she had with a warmth that I’ve sometimes wished I could use to describe the mother I have.

I sometimes wonder what growing up with that absence has done to me. I’ve always had a bit of an angry streak, although whether that’s a consequence of my upbringing or simply a charming personality defect remains open for debate. At the same time, I find myself constantly wanting to be there for other people. I want to listen, help, reassure, and make sure the people around me don’t feel abandoned when things go wrong. Sometimes I do this to the point of exhausting myself, which isn’t particularly healthy either. Maybe the anger and the compulsive need to show up for people come from the same place. Maybe I’m trying to become the person I needed when I was younger. Or maybe I just know how fucking awful it feels to reach out and find nobody there. I haven’t figured that one out, and I’m not going to pretend I have just because it would make for a tidier paragraph.

Now, before someone mistakes this for an attack on religion, it isn’t. I have nothing against prayer or people who find comfort in their faith. I wish my own relationship with God were a little less complicated. But faith is deeply personal. It’s something people discover, question, lose, regain, and negotiate on their own terms. I don’t think it should be prescribed as a substitute for human connection, particularly when the person sitting in front of you isn’t asking for spiritual guidance in the first place.

You can believe in God with every fibre of your being and still sit beside someone who’s having a terrible day. You can pray for them and ask how they’re doing. You can encourage them to have faith while acknowledging that their circumstances are genuinely frightening. These things are not mutually exclusive. In fact, I’d argue that being present for someone is a pretty decent expression of whatever faith you happen to practise. Surely a little compassion here on Earth isn’t going to interfere with whatever arrangements you’ve made with Heaven.

I think what bothers me most is how easily we overlook the courage it sometimes takes for someone to admit they’re struggling. Not everybody is comfortable talking about their feelings, especially men of my generation, many of whom were raised to believe that emotional vulnerability was something best dealt with privately, preferably while staring at a wall and pretending everything was fine. When someone finally tells you they’re scared, anxious, depressed, or simply having a shit time, understand that they may have spent a considerable amount of time working up to that conversation. They’re not necessarily asking you to solve anything. Sometimes they just want to know that somebody gives a damn.

And it doesn’t actually require much. You don’t need a psychology degree, a profound understanding of the human condition, or a carefully rehearsed speech about resilience and personal growth. You don’t even need the right words. Sometimes all it takes is putting your phone down, listening without interrupting, and allowing someone to feel heard. Five minutes of genuine human connection can mean more than an entire khutbah (religious sermon) delivered with the best intentions in the world. It costs nothing except your time, which, when you think about it, is probably one of the more meaningful things you can give another person.

When I first thought of the title for this piece, I found it rather amusing. My Mom Outsourced Emotional Support to God. It sounded like something I could have a bit of fun with. Take the piss out of my upbringing, make a few jokes about religion and parenting, and move on with my day. But the more I thought about it, the sadder it became. Somewhere beneath the sarcasm was a fairly uncomfortable admission that I’ve probably spent much of my life avoiding.

Sometimes, even as a grown man, I need my mother. Not because I expect her to fix my problems or shield me from the consequences of my decisions, but because there are moments when I’d like to feel that I can fall apart a little without being handed a set of instructions on how to put myself back together. I don’t need her to understand every decision I’ve made or every problem I’ve created for myself. I just want to know that when things get difficult, I can turn to her and find a little comfort.

I love my mother. That hasn’t changed, and I don’t imagine it ever will. I also understand that our parents are imperfect people, shaped by their own experiences, beliefs, limitations, and whatever emotional baggage they inherited from the generations before them. I’m old enough to recognise that loving someone and being disappointed by them are not mutually exclusive. Perhaps she’s doing the best she knows how. Perhaps I am too.

I just wish that every now and then, when I reach for my mother, I get my mother.

Not a referral.

Leave an objection.

Comments are held for approval. Your email is never published.